The origins of the dollar sign—or not
The dollar sign is so familiar to us that it’s like another letter of the alphabet. But when you stop to look at “$” as a symbol, it doesn’t make much sense (please excuse the pun).
A “rosette” from a Dominion of Canada bank legal: a bank note exchanged only between chartered banks. 
$50,000, Canada, 1918 NCC 1975.133.0
How on earth did an “S” with a line or two through it come to represent a dollar? Any ideas? No? That’s OK, you’re in good company. Because the truth is, nobody really knows.
But there are a few interesting theories out there. Some seem like conspiracies, others suggest mere accidents of the handwritten word. Most are very plausible, but the one thing they all share is a stubborn unprovability. They all seem to come with a shrug attached.
It is very uncommon for Canadian bank notes to ever carry a “$”. This is an early government bond, a fundraising tool and not exactly a bank note. 1 dollar, debenture, Canada, 1859 NCC 1974.169.30
The American theories
Some say that the dollar sign developed from an abbreviation used on the money bags of the young United States Mint. The letter “U” was superimposed over the “S,” and it takes little imagination to turn that into a dollar sign.
Other historians support the notion that the symbol was first used in documents by two American revolutionary patriots and financiers, Robert Morris and Oliver Pollock. But Pollock and Morris were not writing about the American dollar. They were referring to one of the few hard currencies available to revolutionary Americans, the Spanish-American silver peso—which was also known as a “dollar.” This leads us to our next theory.
The peso theory
Probably the most widely supported theory out there is related to the Spanish-American peso. It was another name for the big, silver 8 reales coin, also known as the piece of eight or dollar.
In the 18th and 19th centuries, Spanish-American coins were the most trusted currency in the world. In documents such as those authored by Morris and Pollock, the peso was sometimes represented as PS or Ps. The two letters began to be written over each other until the P became a mere vertical stroke through the S. There is also a theory that the piece of eight was represented as a P overlaid on an 8, resulting in a similar visual coincidence.
The famous piece of eight, was also called a dollar because of its similar size and weight to the German thalers used in Europe. 8 reales, Spain (Mexico), 1761 NCC 2000.40.305
The Portuguese theory
When is a dollar sign not a dollar sign? When it’s a cifrão. A symbol used on currencies from Portugal and its colonies, the cifrão was used in a very curious way. Though it appears to be a dollar sign, the cifrão actually acts as a decimal point and may have caught on as a broader symbol for money.
Though the Portuguese use the nearly universal Arabic number system, they did not use a decimal or comma in their denominations. 2.5 escudos, Portugal, 1971 NCC 1978.58.1966
The Pillars of Hercules theory
In Greek mythology, Spain and Morocco were once connected by a tall mountain. Hercules created the gateway to the Strait of Gibraltar by breaking through this mountain—with his mighty sword. These great promontories were known as the Pillars of Hercules. The “pillars” have been represented literally as pillars and have together been a symbol of Spain for centuries. They are usually depicted with an S-shaped scroll loosely wrapped around them either together or, more tantalizingly, individually. So common were coins with this image that it’s easy to see them as the root of the dollar sign. But, again, there’s that shrug.
The Pillars of Hercules as seen on the town hall of Seville, Spain. “Plus Ultra” means “further beyond” and is Spain’s national motto. Photo: Ignacio Gavira, Wikimedia Commons
The Pillars of Hercules as seen on a piece of eight. Coins like this circulated all over the world, including in the United States and Canada. 8 reales, Spain (Mexico), 1761 NCC 2000.40.305
The Arab conquest theory
Most theories about the origin of the dollar sign are variations of those described above. One that links two of them is the 8th-century conquest of the Iberian Peninsula (Spain and Portugal) by the Arab General Táriq ibn Ziyád. The difficult route he took from Arabia through Egypt, Libya and Morocco ended by passing between the Pillars of Hercules. It’s suggested that coins minted by Táriq ibn Ziyád featured a wavy line crossed by two vertical lines. This symbol depicted his circuitous route of conquest plus the strength and endurance of the undertaking, as illustrated by bars representing the Pillars of Hercules. This is a theory behind the origin of the cifrão and, consequently, the dollar sign.
Your guess is as good as anybody’s
OK, that last one hasn’t a lot of support among modern historians, but speculations will probably continue to pop up about this fascinating gap in economic history. At this point, however, I should probably open up the floor to suggestions. Yes, you in the back…
We want to hear from you! Do you have an idea for a blog post you’d like to see?
Content type(s):
Blog posts
The Museum Blog
November 28, 2014
The Big Nickel
By: Paul S. Berry
The commemorative 1951 5 cent piece was issued to mark the 200th anniversary of the naming of nickel and its isolation as an element. Recently, I had the great pleasure to participate in the Big Nickel anniversary festivities and give a talk about the design competition for the 1951 5 cent coin.
Content type(s):
Blog posts
November 6, 2014
The Adventure of Exhibit Planning VI
By: Graham Iddon
This is not the time for ‘nay sayers’. Basically, we planned a luxury car knowing that when all was said and done, it was going to be a very nice family sedan (maybe with the big engine?).
Content type(s):
Blog posts
September 29, 2014
The Adventure of Exhibit Planning V
By: Graham Iddon
Now the writer takes a deep breath and attempts to take a subject like the ‘representation of 75 years of national identity as depicted on stamps and bank notes’ from 50 pages of research and squash it into 65 words.
Content type(s):
Blog posts
August 6, 2014
The Senior Deputy Governor’s Signature
By: Graham Iddon
For much of their history, Canadian bank notes have represented a promise, a guarantee that they could be redeemed for “specie” (gold and silver coins) at their parent institution.
Content type(s):
Blog posts
July 28, 2014
Becoming a Collector V
By: Graham Iddon
Suppose you walk into a bar frequented by currency collectors and in an attempt to join in you refer to a ‘planchette’ as a ‘rosette’ (beer mugs hit the tables and the pianist stops playing). This could be pretty humiliating and you’ll probably never be able to go to that bar again, at least not on numismatic night.
Content type(s):
Blog posts
July 21, 2014
Becoming a Collector IV
By: Graham Iddon
Now that you have a grasp of preservation techniques for coins, you might want to familiarize yourself with the finer points of their anatomy. It is all part of your numismatic education and besides, you need to be informed and sound informed when you are buying coins at flea markets or coin fairs.
Content type(s):
Blog posts
